Showing posts with label Lower Manhattan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lower Manhattan. Show all posts
Tuesday, August 6, 2019
Public Art in NYC Chinatown: the Gateways

In 2017 DOT (Department of Transportation) issued an RFP (Request for Proposal) which stated: 

The New York City Department of Transportation, in collaboration with the Chinatown Partnership and Van Alen Institute, is initiating Gateways to Chinatown, a design initiative seeking innovative proposals to plan, design and construct a symbolic and functional landmark at the nexus of Manhattan’s Chinatown and the southern entrance to Little Italy’s historic Mulberry and Mott streets. The overarching goal of the project is to provide a new marker for Chinatown, Little Italy, and the surrounding neighborhoods in Lower Manhattan to engender pride of place, foster connectivity and cultural and social identity, and stimulate economic development. This iconic new structure and public space will be located on a triangular traffic island at a key pedestrian node bounded by Canal Street, Baxter Street and Walker Street. ( June 19, 2017 “Proposal Due Date”)

The effort builds on numerous previous plans, such as the community-consensus building meetings supporting the 1974 “Chinatown Street Revitalization Study” organized by the NYC Department of
 City Planning, “America’s Chinatown: A Community Plan” completed in 2004 by Asian 
Americans for Equality, the Chinese Consolidated Benevolent Association’s 2007 proposal for a gateway at Canal Street, and a 2012-13 collaboration with students of the Urban Design Studio at the New York City College of Technology.

July 19, 2019 AAAC sent the following open letter to DOT after a CB#1 hearing to discuss the RFP results. 

Dear Anthony Notaro (Department of Transportation),

At the Chinatown Gateway meeting I raised the issue of the absence of community input in this process. This has been a historical pattern. This is an opportunity to write you and document some of what this community has experienced including my organization Asian American Arts Centre (AAAC).

AAAC, founded in 1974, began its visual art exhibition program in 1983, and its Public Art in Chinatown in 1988 towards a contemporary image for Chinatown and Asian Americans. Mel Chin was in that exhibition – now so prominent, he also submitted a proposal to this Gateway project through AAAC in 2017 but somehow he was disqualified.

Several community people are here for this meeting even though news of it we only a few days ago, For years there has been little if any effort to speak to community. Govt agencies for decades have sustained a pattern of city state and federal actions to push through projects regardless of community.

It was mentioned how twelve years ago planning for this triangle began. The five nfp (not-for-profit) arts organizations were promised how the marketing of our cultural offerings would be promoted by the kiosk built there. Though we met with the designer of the map that is used by so many visitors there he could not change the map nor include any of the other nfp groups. Only MoCA was included. The kiosk mostly promotes Broadway plays and even the young people staffing it are resistant to including local cultural event flyers.

Twelve years ago CPLDC (Chinatown Partnership Local Development Corporation) sought 5 gate options be considered but could never get past NYC Arts Commission and their bias against anything traditional. Unlike San Francisco and many other American cities where traditional architectural forms are welcome. The gate proposed for Canal St was not allowed and thus restricted to the triangle off Baxter St.

This was not the first time public art has been proposed on this site. I recall being asked for a written piece many years ago on a proposal for work quite similar to what stands by Seward Park on Essex and East Broadway. It is a dark reddish monumental shape. Phallic stone fountains across Asia look very similar. The one proposed for Baxter St was white marble.

If I had to speak to the image of the proposed public art project I would refer back to this history. This time it's a phallic shape in denial, thus it is sliced up into cylinders and punctured with holes.


How to account for such a disconnect between government agencies and the communities they are to serve? The last comment from CB 1 in reviewing the proposal and hearing community comments was, “The procurement process is flawed!”. I felt the comments from the board members were quite fair and insightful in describing the image and experience if the proposed piece were installed. Particularly the final comment seemed to take into account the whole track record of this project.

In the community we can recall the public art of Marshall Lin that stands in Chatham Square. When it was installed it had several plaques with statements about the history, why Marshall Lin was being honored having fought against the British in the Opium War and was the first to say 'No" to drugs. About a year later the Arts Commission removed all to clean but would not return those plaques.

Last year a book was published in Hawaii called Abstract Expressionism: Looking East from the Far West - in which it was noted, now widely accepted how Clement Greenberg, the advocate for abstract expressionism in the 60s, claimed only for political motives 'Action Painting' had nothing to do with the Asian tradition of calligraphic brush work. And recently the art critic John Yau commented there were still some critics of his ilk in NYC. The resistance to an Asian cultural presence in New York's cultural circles is something to contend with. Unfortunately the local community is more deeply impacted by this bias than most realize.

Lawrence Ferlinghetti wrote in one of his poem that the city fathers allow the Chinese dragon out to dance through San Francisco Chinatown once a year only to lock it back up into a basement hovel.

When will the time come when cultural diversity, particularly with the cultures of Asia, be regarded as a asset, not just for museum walls.

Bob Lee

AAAC catalogue: Public Art in Chinatown 1988



A letter written to DOT and Gateway applicants in June, 2017 

Dear Potential Gateways to Chinatown Applicants,

Asian American Arts Centre as an visual arts organization that has specialized on Asian American artists, offers insights into the sensibility of many such artists during this opportunity to apply for Canal Street “Gate” RFP. These selected artists' images may serve as an introduction or as a compliment to your knowledge and experience.

Local prominence


Tomie Arai 

Corky Lee


Relay to public art 


Mel Chin

Ming Fay

Mei Ling Hom (1)      (2) 

Soon Im Kim

Mikyung Kim

Toshinori Kuga

Yin Peet


Unlike mainstream

Sung Ho Choi

Ken Fukushima

Eunjung Hwang

Heejung Kim (1)       (2) 


Reinvented Asian sensibility

Chao Chung-Hsiang

Emily Cheng

Columbia Fiero

John Yoyogi Fortes

Colette Fu

Hisako Hibi

Sin-ying Ho

Yun Fei Ji

Mike Kanemitsu

Jung Hyang Kim

Amy Kao


Community motifs


Sung Ho Choi

Fung Ming Chip

Nancy Hom

Teh Ching Hsieh

Ming Fay


Racial perceptions 

Wei In Chen 

Kazuko Miyamoto

Roger Shimomura

Tseng Kwong Chi

Charles Yuen


Famous


Teh Ching Hsieh

Mel Chin 


Aesthetic ‘expansion arts’


Soon Im Kim


James Kuo 

Amy Loewan

If you wish I can give a brief intro to any of these artists you chose.


With Kind Regards,

Bob
Read more
Thursday, May 11, 2017
Archival Alchemy: South Asian Women's Creative Collective

Archives play an integral role in daily life, yet they often remain obscured or overlooked. They allow viewers to receive glimpses of the past, of a life that they never experienced, and help reconstruct history; They become a foundation of knowledge and information for the academics and curious; They contribute to the formation and continuous evolution of identity. The form archives take are not restricted by documents, literature, or visual mediums: in fact, they are all around us. The clothes we wear, the objects we possess, and the things we carry on a daily basis: these are only a handful of examples of archives, items that can be used to reconstruct history and transform identities. The contributions archives make are, again, often disregarded or obscured because there are not many people who can identify the numerous forms they can take on. Thankfully, at the Abrons Arts Center, the true extent of archives was exposed.

Archival Alchemy
Photo by Bob Lee
Archival Alchemy: South Asian Women's Creative Collective was an exhibition, curated by Saisha Grayson, that used an assortment of archives in order to explore issues relating to assimilation,  marginalization, representation, and identity. Thirteen female South Asian artists contributed pieces that examined the history and present stance of South Asian women. Here is an official statement from South Asian Women's Creative Collective:

"At a moment when South Asian communities, women, and immigrant neighborhoods like the Lower East Side are being targeted by an evidence-averse administration, ​this exhibition will also offer an opportunity for nuanced reflection on the complex global and personal histories that shape conflicting views of our contemporary moment. Several works explore the role that archives play in creating official histories, papering over dissent and managing the disappearance of non-citizens, while others present or produce counter archives that resist such erasure and offer strategies for empowerment."

At the exhibition, an assortment of aesthetically-pleasing and personal pieces were displayed, all which provided political and social commentary on the lives of South Asian women. Here are a few examples of the pieces featured in the exhibition:

I Never "Ask for It" by Blank Noise:
Gathering together thousands of garments worn by those experiencing sexual harassment or violence, the ongoing project "counters the lie that women 'ask for it' through calmative, collectively-built testimonials reporting the truth of widespread, unchecked, unprovoked sexual aggression." The individuals who submitted clothes are labeled as "Action Heroes" -- ordinary citizen-participants taking action to tackle sexual assault. The diversity in styles -- children's cartoon t-shirts, modest cardigans, beach dresses, sweatshirts, and pajamas -- proves that "there is no outfit that women can wear that will stop what is ultimately a societal problem -- an entrenched rape culture that extends from excusing 'locker room talk,' ignoring street harassment, shame sexual assault victims, and failing to punish rapists, abusive spouses, and murderous partners to the full extend of the law." The display was supported by both text and audio clips.

 Garments Worn by Women Experiencing Sexual Harassment or Violence
Photo by Baie Rogers
 Garments Worn by Women Experiencing Sexual Harassment or Violence
Photo by Baie Rogers
The Scheherazade Project by Amy Khoshbin*:
The Scheherazade Project is a multimedia project that "merges live performance and an original score with animated Persian illustrations, images from the Iranian Revolution, found and newly created film footage, and immersive video game tropes to explore the power of storytelling, past and present." To view the entire feature, please feel free to click the link provided: https://vimeo.com/198574125

A Snippet from the Video
Photo by Baie Rogers
Another Snippet from the Video
Photo by Bob Lee
*The AAAC has written an extended piece about Amy Khoshbin. Please feel free to find the post on our blog.

Past and Present by Zinnia Naqvi:
Naqvi's series "uses family albums as a dynamic archives through which intergenerational identity construction and legacies of migration can be more precisely understood." There are two sets of photographs: one is an archival image that presents an migrant parent standing in their countries of origin; the second photograph is Naqvi's attempt to restage the original photograph using the parent's children. The process "reveals resonances that derive not only from familial resemblance, but from the children's tendency to be drawn towards or to create environments that offer points of connectivity."

Zinnia Naqvi's Project Past and Present
Image From Booklet
A Close Up
Photo by Bob Lee
Troy Towers by Patience Rustomji:
In her piece, discarded objects collected from her apartment complex are placed into glass vases, of all shapes and sizes, and are submerged in "cooking oil and spices traditionally used to preserve food" that were repurposed from her mother's kitchen. Rustomji "attempts to create an 'eternal present' for this imagined by invisible community by transforming detritus redolent of urban dislocation and alienation into 'a personal archive of desire, fantasy, and longing.'"

Patience Rustomji's Troy Towers
Image From Booklet

Another Vantage Point
Photo by Bob Lee
Perfect Love and Other Stories by Marium Agha:
Constructed with embroidery, recycled imagery, and found tapestries, Agha "dissects myths of love that accumulate across cultures, obscuring real experiences that run counter to formulaic fairytales." The rabbit featured in below is flayed, exposing threads and muscles. The pieces -- not displayed below is portrait that recreates Alice's White Rabbit, only it is instead made up of yarn and rope on fabric -- "court sensuous responses that, like their subject, exceed rationality."

Marium Agha's Perfect Love and Other Stories
Photo by Bob Lee

Index of the Disappeared by Chitra Ganesh and Miriam Ghani:
Following 9/11, there was a drastic shift in views towards security, privacy, Muslims, and immigrants. The ongoing archival project "is continually expanding to reflect the proliferating bureaucratic and legal mechanisms, and to appose the shift towards secrecy surveillance, and censorship, that have accompanied an unprecedented of disseverances, deportations, renditions, and detentions since 2001." The Index also provides "documents tracing the connections between increased immigrations enforcement and chilled speech, racial profiling, media representations of people of color, prison labor, the private prison industry, abuse in detention, corruption in ICE, militarization of the US-Mexio border, and the xenophobic histories of the 96 Laws, Japanese internment, and the Asian Exclusion Act."


The Index of the Disappeared 
Photo by Bob Lee
100 Days/16 Years
Photo by Bob Lee
Archival Alchemy achieved so much within it's small space: the exhibition provided a platform for an often overlooked demographic -- South Asian women -- to present their voices; the installations helped highlight complex but relevant issues that continue to shape the lives of every individual; the artists who contributed work brilliantly reminds viewers that archives are more than items: they are our stories and our identities.

On May 7th, Many of the Artists Held a Panel to Discuss Their Work
Photo by Bob Lee 
Links:
For more information about Archival Alchemy: South Asian Women's Creative Collection: http://www.sawcc.org/archival-alchemy-sawccs-20th-anniversary-exhibition/
For more information about the Abrons Art Center: http://www.abronsartscenter.org
For more information about Blank Noise and their ongoing project I Never "Ask for It": http://www.ineveraskforit.org/blank-noise
For more information about Amy Koshbin: http://tinyscissors.com
For more information about Zinnia Naqvi: http://www.zinnianaqvi.com
For more information about Patience Rustomji: http://www.patiencerustomji.com
For more information about Marium Agha: https://www.artsy.net/artist/marium-agha
For more information about Index of the Disappeared: http://www.mariamghani.com/work/626 
Read more
Thursday, April 6, 2017
Rally for the Arts!!


On April 3rd, an assortment of artists gathered at New York City Hall in order to protest against Donald Trump’s plan to exterminate all outlays for the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA), the National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH), the Corporation for Public Broadcasting (CPB), and the Institute of Museum of Library Services (IMLS).

A View From the Outside
Photo by Baie Rogers
Inside
Photo by Bob Lee
As explained in a previous post about the NEA, the Federal Budget in 2016 was approximately $3.871 trillion; both the NEA and the NEH spent around $148,000,000 within the budget, which is, according to Washington Post’s Philip Bump, is only 0.03% of the overall budget — The NEA gave $14.5 million to 419 groups in New York City last year. However, Trump’s administration still wants to relocate money away from domestic (art) programs, and towards security and defense  — the proposed budget increases the two departments by $54 billion overall. 

The Rally to Save the Arts united a wide spectrum of artists who represent both the visual and performing arts: independent artists, the Asian American Arts Centre, the Actor’s Equity Association, New York Musician’s Union, and The Poetry Society of New York are some examples. 


Chuck Yeun, Whose Work is Featured in the AAAC's Permanent Collection, Attended the Rally
Photo by Bob Lee
Dion Chen Supporting the Actor's Equity Association
Photo by Bob Lee
DANCE EDUCATION FOR EVERY CHILD!
Photo by Baie Rogers
There were also some highly prestigious guest speakers, such as Queens Councilman and chair of the Cultural Affairs Committee, Jimmy Van Bramer. “President Trump’s budget is an unprecedented and vicious assault on the arts, the humanities, libraries,” he said. “President Trump talks a lot about making America great again, but you can never make anything great again by crushing its soul.”
Sami Shumays (Left): Founder and Director of Zikrayat -- Peter Koo (Right): Councilman (D-Flushing)
Photo by Bob Lee
Former Talking Heads frontman David Byrne also spoke at the Rally. He viewed Trump’s plan from a more economic lens. “You may hate the arts. You may hate the stuff that people paint and the theater that they do, but do you want to lose all those jobs? Do we want to kill this part of the economy? That’s just completely stupid.” He extends his argument in a self-written blog post, entitled What Good Are the Arts?:
“A recent study called Arts and Economic Prosperity found that nationally the non-profit arts (we're not talking about Broadway shows, pop concerts, video games, movies or the art world) generates $135.2 BILLION in economic activity in the US… In 2013, the production of arts and cultural goods added more than $704 billion to the U.S. economy. This amounts to 4.23% of GDP. The arts and cultural sector contribute more to the national economy than do the construction, agriculture, mining, utilities, and travel and tourism sectors.”


ALTERNATE FACTS
Photo by Bob Lee


City Council Speaker Melissa Mark-Viverito recalled the cultural impact the arts had left on her. “I came here at the age of 18, but my mother made it a point to take us to museums, to take us to the theater.” She later added, “Art and culture enhanced my life, gave me a perspective, an understanding of the world we live in, of our collective wellbeing, that we are not in this alone. That we can reach across the aisle and learn about other cultures, create a sense of understanding and camaraderie.”
SAVE THE ARTS Written in Five Languages: English, Spanish, Chinese, Korean, and Scottish Gaelic
Photo by Baie Rogers
The Protester Who Held the Sign SAVE THE ARTS in Five Languages
Photo by Baie Rogers
Actress Ciara Renée defended the arts by highlighting it’s more psychological impact. She said that the arts is a “collaboration of what is with what can be” and a “connection to something higher and more powerful than any stagnation or destruction and abundance, a surplus…Does that sound bad to you?” she said. “So it’s a wonder why the powers that be wanna take an ax to it, stop it in its tracks when it’s already placed at the bottom of the totem pole of existence?”

Jelani Remy, who portrays Simba in Broadway’s The Lion King, contributed his own personal stories relating to how important the arts were to him as a kid. He then lead the crowd, outside City Hall, in a rendition of “Over the Rainbow.” 

"Below is a picture of a high school senior who, when asked which of the arts she attributed to saving her life, she said, 'The visual arts.' I had a feeling that I had just taken a picture of the most profound sign at the Rally. So, let me thank Sara(h) for taking her picture." -Bob
ART SAVED MY LIFE
Photo by Bob Lee 
To quote Jimmy Van Bramer, "He [Trump] has come for artists and the cultural community today but first, the president came after Mexicans, then Muslims, then immigrants—including the undocumented—then it was the trans youth of our country, then the health of millions of Americans with Trumpcare and now he comes for us. But he was defeated on Trumpcare, wasn’t he? Because of rallies just like this. People taking to the streets saying that we will not accept this, this is not who we are. We are better than this.”

National Priorities Statistics: https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-budget-101/spending/


Read more
Sunday, January 15, 2017
ZONED OUT!


At the Abrons Arts Center on Dec 12 2016, the authors of the book "Zoned Out!" and community organizers gathered to discuss the racial segregation, gentrification and displacement in neighborhoods like the Lower East Side and Chinatown.

Speakers:
Tom Angotti is Professor of Urban Policy and Planning at Hunter College, the Graduate Center, and City University of New York, and Director of the Hunter College Center for Community Planning & Development. He is author of New York For Sale: Community Planning Confronts Global Real Estate, which won the 2009 Davidoff Book Award.

Samuel Stein is a PhD student in Geography at the CUNY Graduate Center and holds a master’s degree in Urban Planning from Hunter College. In addition to teaching and studying urban geography, he worked as a researcher, organizer, and planner on numerous New York City union campaigns, tenant mobilizations, and public policy initiatives. 

Louise Velez is a native Puerto Rican and a long-time Lower East Side resident. In the 1970s she began organizing with fellow residents against unsafe housing conditions, evictions and displacement in the neighborhood. Velez is a member of Mujeres y Hombres Luchadores, and a Board Member of National Mobilization Against SweatShops (NMASS), where she is currently organizing public housing residents to demand repairs and to stop the sale of public land and assets.

Jei Fong is a staff member of Chinese Staff & Workers' Association with over 10 years of experience organizing workers in the workplace and community.

Sylvia Morse received her Master of Urban Planning degree from CUNY Hunter College, where she focused on housing and participatory planning. She is a lifelong New Yorker who has worked with community-based and nonprofit organizations dedicated to affordable housing, community-based planning, and racial and economic justice. 





Read more